Lyman Thomas Marshall - parttime from 1813 to 1817

Lyman George Walker - February 1818 to April 1831

The Reverend Appleton Belnap - June 1832 to October 1833

The Reverend George Waters - September 1834 to March 1838

The Reverend Samuel Everett - June 1838 to April 1839

The Reverend Andrew Pollard - August 1840 to April 1843

The Reverend Woodman H. Watson - June 1843 to April 1847

The Reverend Josiah H. Tilton - November 1848 to 1852

The Reverend Andrew Dunn - 1853

The Reverend Timothy C. Tingley - 1854 to 1856

The Reverend Josiah H. Tilton - 1857 to 1859

The Reverend Lester Williams, Jr. - July 1859 to 1864

The Reverend John S. Haradon - 1865 to 1868

The Reverend George W. Kinney - 1869 to 1871

The Reverend John Rounds - 1872 to 1874

The Reverend John K. Chase - 1874 to 1879

The Reverend Isaac S. Hamblen - 1880 to 1886

The Reverend David F. Estes - 1886 to 1891

The Reverend Benjamin H. Lane - April 1892 to 1894

The Reverend Joseph Walther - January 1895 to March 1902

The Reverend Alfred E. Alton - September 1902 to January 1906

The Reverend Ralph E. Story - 1906 to 1907

The Reverend Simeon Spidle - 1908 to 1910

The Reverend Wesley DeJardins - 1911

The Reverend james Warren Leonard - 1914 to 1925

The Reverend Harold Heyward - 1926 to 1929

The Reverend Elmer C. Adams - 1930 to 1940

The Reverend Newton E. Woodbury - March 1940 to 1945

The Reverend Clarence G. Strippy - January 1946 to July

The Reverend Willard S. Smith - August 1946 to November 1946

The Reverend Hartley T. Grandin - December 1946 to December 1958

The Reverend Harold Curtis - December 1958 to April 1959

The Reverend Rober E. Baggs - April 1959 to April 1968

The Reverend Donald D. Menzel - September 1968 to August 1973

The Reverend Quentin C. Sewell - September 1973 to November 1973

The Reverend George L. Middleton - December 1973 to